Family Guy on SCOTUS Justice Kavanaugh visits a brewery and then switches places with Peter Griffin. Reason · Mar 11, 2025
There is Some Drama Brewing In San Francisco v. EPA Today the Court decided one case, San Francisco v. EPA. As I predicted, the majority opinion was assigned to Justice Alito.… The post There is Some Drama Brewing In San Francisco v. EPA appeared first on Reason.com. Reason · Mar 4, 2025
Did Glossip and the Oklahoma Attorney General Collusively Conceal Evidence to Win Their U.S. Supreme Court Case? Justice Thomas observes in his dissent that "the parties collusively excluded" evidence—which I presented to the Court for the victim's family—"in order to reach a predetermined outcome." And the Court majority offers no defense of this deceitful maneuver. Reason · Feb 25, 2025
Authorship Predictions for the October Sitting It is never too early to make predictions! Reason · Feb 25, 2025
Justices Sotomayor and Gorsuch on the Fourth Amendment and Misdemeanor Arrests "Founding-era common law gave officers no authority to make an 'arrest without a warrant, for a mere misdemeanor not committed in [their] presence.'" Reason · Feb 24, 2025
The TikTok Majority Opinion Here's a quick summary of the unsigned majority opinion (called a "per curiam"), joined by all the Justices except Justice… The post The TikTok Majority Opinion appeared first on Reason.com. Reason · Jan 17, 2025
All The Things TikTok v. Garland Did Not Decide CTRL-F the decision for "need not" and "assume" Reason · Jan 17, 2025
Some Legal Questions About Greenland, Puerto Rico, and Alberta I realize many of the things that Trump says have no chance of becoming reality. But it is foolish to… The post Some Legal Questions About Greenland, Puerto Rico, and Alberta appeared first on Reason.com. Reason · Jan 10, 2025
Talking to the Justices About References ABC News reports, "Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito spoke to President-elect Donald Trump by phone Tuesday to recommend one of… The post Talking to the Justices About References appeared first on Reason.com. Reason · Jan 9, 2025
Justice Alito spars over trans rights with first openly trans attorney at the Supreme Court The court’s liberal justices fear conservatives are ‘undermining the bedrock’ of discrimination protections The Independent UK · Dec 4, 2024
More Leaks in the NY Times About The "Supreme Court Ethics Debate" Jodi Kantor reports on a confidential ten-page memo from Justices Gorsuch, and comments from Justices Thomas and Alito. Reason · Dec 3, 2024
Must Government Pay Compensation When It Damages Innocent Owner's Property in Police Action? From Justice Sotomayor's opinion today respecting denial of certiorari in Baker v. City of McKinney, joined by Justice Gorsuch: The… The post Must Government Pay Compensation When It Damages Innocent Owner's Property in Police Action? appeared first on Reason.com. Reason · Nov 25, 2024
Justices Alito and Sotomayor on How Courts Read Dicta An amusing and potentially revealing exchange in a recent oral argument. Reason · Oct 19, 2024
Justice Sotomayor Asks Texas Governor Abbott To Grant Executive Reprieve To Death Row Prisoner Case of the Speluncean Explorers Redux Reason · Oct 18, 2024
Reason · Sep 15, 2024 NY Times Big Reveals On Deliberations In Three Trump Cases How did Roberts come to write Trump v. Anderson, Fischer v. United States, and Trump v. United States?
Reason · Aug 17, 2024 Severability on the Shadow Docket: SCOTUS Splits 5-4 On Whether Entirety of Title IX Regulations Must Be Enjoined Justice Gorsuch joins the three dissenters on severability. What about Justices Thomas and Barrett?
Reason · Jul 29, 2024 Thoughts on Biden's Proposed Supreme Court Reforms The proposals include term limits for Supreme Court justices, a binding ethics code, and a constitutional amendment limiting the president's' immunity from prosecution. All 3 are potentially good ideas. But devil is in details.
Reason · Jul 29, 2024 The Behind the Scenes Wrangling in the Idaho Abortion Case Joan Biskupic reports that the justices were initially inclined to back Idaho in the EMTALA case, until they realized the case was messier than they had thought.
Reason · Jul 25, 2024 Jarkesy Should Not Have Been So Easy For Justice Barrett There are tensions between Jarkesy, CFPB, and Vidal.
Reason · Jul 23, 2024 Chief Justice Roberts, The Judicial Supremacist in Jarkesy The Chief Justice wavers on many issues, but never in returning power to the federal judiciary.
Reason · Jul 22, 2024 Atlas Roofing Shrugged Another Burger Court precedent is about to be “abandoned” or “overruled” like Roe, Lemon, Chevron, Abood, and Bakke.
Reason · Jul 9, 2024 The Supreme Court Refuses To Extend Robinson v. California, A Non-Originalist Decision Even if an erroneous precedent cannot be overruled, isolate the damage, and decline to extend it to new circumstances.
Reason · Jul 5, 2024 Justice Sotomayor Would Deny Immunity For Abuses of Power, Corrupt Purposes, and Personal Gain Justice Sotomayor's rhetoric in Trump v. United States mirrors the claims from Trump impeachment 1.0
Reason · Jul 4, 2024 Trump v. United States Recognizes That Prosecuting The President Poses More Risks Than Suing The President Defenders of the Mueller investigation routinely argued that the threat of civil enforcement was worse than a federal prosecution.
Reason · Jul 3, 2024 What Exactly Do Justices Thomas and Gorsuch Disagree About In Loper Bright Justice Thomas agrees with the "lion's share" of Justice Gorsuch's concurrence.